EU law
EU case law
International case law
National case law
Case law search by referred act / provision
Legal act
Provision
Recent summarised cases
 
 
EuroCases Keywords

Right of deduction, Taxable transaction, Vehicles rented, Submission of rentals to value added tax, Directive 2006/112/EC - Articles 168 and 176

EuroCases Summary

In the present case, the Council of State (Conseil d’Etat) was required to rule on the disregard of the provisions of Directive 2006/112/EC.

The company DBF Montpellier asked the Council of State to annul for abuse of power the words "provided that this rental was subject to VAT. The vehicles must

... show more

 
Document EuroCases Keywords

Electricity production, State responsibility, State delay in transposing a Directive, Taxation of energy products, Internal tax on natural gas consumption, Exemption from internal tax on final electricity consumption, Small power producers, Failure to transpose, Decision pursuant to preliminary ruling, Directive 2003/96/EC - Articles 14 (1) (a), 18 (10) and 21 (5) (3)

EuroCases Summary

In the present case, the Administrative Court of Appeal of Versailles (Cour administrative d'appel de Versailles) was required to rule on the disregard of the Directive 2003/96/EC.

The company SAS UPM France asked the Administrative Court of Appeal of Versailles to annul the judgment of the

... show more

 
Document EuroCases Keywords

Differences in treatment between fixed-term and permanent workers, Principle of non-discrimination, Abusive renewal of successive fixed-term contracts, Irregularity of the fixed-term employment contract, Directive 1999/70/EC

EuroCases Summary

In the present case, the Administrative Court of Appeal of Douai (Cour administrative d'appel de Douai) was required to rule on the application of the objectives of Directive 1999/70/EC.

Mr. A ... asked the Administrative Court of Appeal of Douai to annul the judgment of the Administrative Court of

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Opinion of the environmental authority, Authorization request, Objective opinion on the project concerned, Consulting mission, Real autonomy, Public authority competent to authorize a project, Environmental assessment of projects likely to have significant effects on the environment, Assessment of the impact of certain public and private projects on the environment, Directive 2011/92/EU - Article 6, Directive 2001/42/EC - Article 6

EuroCases Summary

In the present case, the Council of State (Conseil d’Etat) was required to rule on the disregard of the provisions of Directive 2011/92/EU.

Mr. and Mrs. U ... asked the Council of State to annul the judgment of the Administrative Court of Appeal Nantes (Cour administrative d'appel de Nantes) which

... show more

 
Document EuroCases Keywords

Tax domiciliation, Social contributions, Heritage income, European social security scheme, Principle of uniqueness of social legislation, Discharge of social security contributions, Regulation (EC) No 883/2004, Regulation (EEC) No 1408/71

EuroCases Summary

In the present case, the Administrative Court of Appeal of Nancy (Cour administrative d'appel de Nancy) was required to rule on the disregard of the provisions of Regulation (EC) No 883/2004.

Mr. and Mrs. A ... asked the Administrative Court of Appeal of Nancy to annul the judgment of the

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Dominant position, Public interest, Right of competition, Freedom of trade, Principle of free administration, Information system, Civil security, Public service mission, Administrative public establishment, Digital Civil Security Agency, Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union - Articles 102 and 106

EuroCases Summary

In the present case, the Council of State (Conseil d’Etat) was required to rule on the disregard of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU).

The Qualisis association, the System and Telecommunications company and the Midi-Pyrénées IT company asked the Council of State to annul for

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Entbindung eines Kindes, Rechtliches Interesse, Diensthabende Hebamme, Art 9 Abs 1,2 f;23 Abs 1;4 Abs 1,2;6 Abs 1 f DSGVO, Art 47 GRC, Vorabentscheidung des Europäischen Gerichtshofs gem. Art 267 AEUV, Umgehung der Opferrechte im Strafverfahren, Geheimhaltungsinteresse an den Privat/ Familienlebens /Gesundheitsdaten, Verteidigung im Strafverfahren, Antrag auf Akteneinsicht und Übermittlung des Urteils

EuroCases Summary

Die Kläger begehrten von der beklagten Spitalserhalterin Schadenersatz wegen medizinischen Behandlungsfehlern an der Klägerin und an ihrem verstorbenen Kind im Zuge der Entbindung. Die Einschreiterin stellte einen Antrag auf Akteneinsicht und Übermittlung des Urteils sowie der Beschlüsse,

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Art. 8 Abs.1 EMRK, Art 99 Abs 2 der Verordnung (EU) 2016/679 des Europäischen Parlaments und des Rates, Daten auf Firmenlaptop, Art. 17,79 Abs. 1,6,9,10, 88,2 DSGVO, vorbeugenden Unterlassungsklage, Sensible Daten, Rechtmäßigkeit der Verarbeitung der Daten, Löschungsanspruch bzgl. Daten, Rekonstruierung von den Daten

EuroCases Summary

Dem Kläger war im Rahmen seines Dienstverhältnisses ein Laptop zur Verfügung gestellt worden. Nach der Entlassung retournierte der Kläger der Beklagten den Laptop, wobei er einen Ordner „D:\privat“ gelöscht hatte. Die Beklagte beauftragte ein Unternehmen mit der Rekonstruierung von den Daten. Der

... show more

 
Document EuroCases Keywords

Art. 47 GRC, Art. 6 Abs. 1 EMRK, Richtlinie 95/46/EG, Artikel 16 der Verordnung (EU) 2016/679, Spruchpunkt der Beschwerdevorentscheidung, Verbesserungsfähiger Mangel, Behauptungs- und Beweislast, Abweisung der Beschwerde wegen Verletzung im Recht auf Berichtigung, Zurückweisung der Beschwerde wegen Verletzung im Recht auf Geheimhaltung, Grundrecht auf Datenschutz, Recht auf Auskunft

EuroCases Summary

Der Beschwerdeführer hat eine Beschwerde nach dem DSG eingebracht, er sei in seinem Grundrecht auf Datenschutz, im Recht auf Auskunft, sowie im Recht auf Berichtigung verletzt worden. Eine Referentin der Beschwerdegegnerin hat ein Telefongespräch mit der Kriminalpolizei geführt und Sachverhalte aus

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Art. 6 para. 1 lit. e, paragraphs 2 and 3 lit. b GDPR, Art. 4 No. 2 GDPR, Art. 6 para. 1 lit. a GDPR, Article 4 No. 1 GDPR, Directive 95/46 / EC, Art. 4 No. 1 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679, Art. 7 para. 1 of Regulation (EU) No. 260/2012, Right to inspect personal data, Personal data to be protected, Request inspection, Decision of the patent department of the German Patent and Trademark Office to inspect files and direct debit mandates

EuroCases Summary

The complaint is against the decision of the patent department of the Patent and Trademark Office, which partially granted the patent proprietor's request for inspection of the payment transactions of another.

The Federal Patent Court (BpatG) is of the opinion that access to own file is based on

... show more

 
Document EuroCases Keywords

Art. 8 Abs. 2 EMRK, Richtlinie 95/46/EG (Datenschutz-Grundverordnung), Verordnung (EU) 2016/679, Grundsatz der "Erforderlichkeit", Übermaßverbot als Ausdruck des Verhältnismäßigkeitsgrundsatzes, Zulässigkeit der Datenermittlung, Datenschutzrechtliche Beschwerden, Recht auf Geheimhaltung schutzwürdiger personenbezogener Daten

EuroCases Summary

Die mitbeteiligte Partei hat eine Beschwerde nach § 31 Abs. 2 DSG 2000 eingebracht, sie sei in ihrem Recht auf Geheimhaltung schutzwürdiger personenbezogener Daten verletzt worden, indem die Beschwerdeführerin in einem sie nicht betreffenden Bescheid ihre personenbezogenen Daten, wie konkrete

... show more

 
Document EuroCases Keywords

Rechtsbeschränkung, Datenminimierung, Pflegefreistellung, Personenbezogene Daten, Lebenswichtiges Interesse, Krankenstand, Grundrechtseingriff, Gesundheitsdaten, Gelindestes Mittel, Geheimhaltungsinteresse, Datenverarbeitung, Datenspeicherung

EuroCases Summary

§ 69 Abs. 4 DSG enthält keine Übergangsbestimmungen bezüglich der anhängigen Verfahren in Datenschutzangelegenheiten vor dem Bundesverwaltungsgericht. Damit ist die zum Zeitpunkt einer Beschlussfassung geltende Rechtslage anzuwenden.

Bei Informationen über den Krankenstandstag und über den

... show more

 
Document EuroCases Keywords

Regelungslücke, Verwaltungsgerichtsbarkeit, Inkrafttreten, Anhängige Verfahren, Datenschutzgesetzes 2000, Übergangsbetimmungen

EuroCases Summary

Die Übergangsbestimmungen des § 69 Abs. 4 und 5 Datenschutzgesetzes 2000 regeln welches Recht zum Zeitpunkt seines Inkrafttretens bei anhängigen Verfahren von der Datenschutzbehörde und der ordentlichen Gerichten anzuwenden ist. Die anhängige Verfahren sind nach den Bestimmungen dieses

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Transportation by air, Place of performance for a passenger transportation on two flights, Regulation № 261/2004 - Article 7 (1), Jurisdiction of the courts for passengers' compensations

EuroCases Summary

The plaintiffs in the case concerned seek a compensation of € 600 under Article 7 (1) (1) (c) of Regulation (EC) No 261/2004 (Passenger Rights Regulation) and a default interest due to a delay of a flight from Yekaterinburg to Helsinki, which was executed by the defendant and was due to land at

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Admissibility of data processing due to the interests of a third party, Death of account holder of online social network, General Data Protection Regulation, Data protection in the telecommunications

The plaintiff in the present case is mother of a girl who died at the age of fifteen. She is beside the father a member of the community of heirs after her daughter. The defendant operates a social network through whose infrastructure users can communicate with each other via the internet and

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Advertising in the electronic communication, Encroachment on the general personal rights, Protection of the privacy of users in the electronic communications, Data Protection Directive - Article 13 (1), Processing of personal data

EuroCases Summary

This plaintiff in the present case ordered goods through an internet platform and did not wish to receive emails in which the gratitude for the purchase of the certain item was connected with a request to participate in a customer satisfaction survey. The plaintiff sees in the e-mail an unsolicited

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Suspension of the proceedings because of a remedy in the State of origin, European civil procedural law, Application for a suspension of the proceedings, Recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments

EuroCases Summary

The claimants requested in the case concerned that a judgment of the Krakow Appeal Court is declared enforceable domestically. In its well-founded appeal lodged on time, the respondent wishes to obtain the annulment of the decisions of the lower instance courts and the dismissal of the application

... show more

 
Document EuroCases Keywords

Dispute with cross-border reference, Scope of application of Directive 2003/8/EC, Reference for preliminary ruling, Directive 2003/8/EC - Article 12

EuroCases Summary

In the present case, the Federal Labor Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht) had to decide whether the plaintiff was entitled to legal aid for the costs incurred for the translation into German of the necessary annexes to the legal aid application.

First, the Court of Appeal clarified that, under German law,

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Infringement of intellectual property rights

EuroCases Summary

The case at hand is centered on the alleged infringement of trademarks (both EU and UK) under Article 9(2)(c) of Council Regulation (EC) No. 207/2009 and its corresponding UK provisions. The defendant in the proceedings, a dog food manufacturer and seller, sought to register a trademark over a

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Realistic prospect of removal, Detention with view of expulsion, Lawfulness of detention of foreign national

EuroCases Summary

The High Court was asked to review the lawfulness of the detention of a Somali national (the claimant) by the Secretary of State for the Home Department (the defendant). The claimant had been detained upon his release from prison with view of extradition to Somalia. However, extradition proved

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Validiy of marriage, Spouse to an EU national, Refusal of application for residence card

EuroCases Summary

In a challenge to a decision to refuse the issuance of a residence card, the Court of Appeal was asked to consider the basis, on which third country marriages are recognised in the UK for the purposes of Article 2 of Directive 2004/38/EC. The appellant was a Ghanaian national, who had applied for a

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Principle of mutual trust and confidence, Proportionality of a European arrest warrant

EuroCases Summary

In an appeal from a lower court, concerning extradition proceedings, the High Court was asked to consider the proportionality of a European Arrest Warrant, issued by Belgian Authorities for a Lithuanian woman, residing in the UK. Since the issuance of the EAW, the circumstances of the Lithuanian

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Challenge to the validity of a supplementary protection certificate

EuroCases Summary

The High Court was asked to consider the proper construction and application of Article 3(c) of Regulation 469/2009/EC. The claimant in the case challenged the validity of a supplementary protection certificate, issued for a medical product on grounds of incompliance of Article 3(a) and (c) of the

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Acquired distinctiveness, Refusal of trademark registration

EuroCases Summary

In an appeal to a refused registration of a trademark, the High Court was asked to consider the proper construction of Article 7, para. 3 of Council Regulation (EC) No 40/94. The appellant was refused registration of a trademark, consisting of a single word, on the grounds that said word was

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Tax fraud - burden of proof, Reality of the delivery - burden of proof, Constriction works

EuroCases Summary

The revenue authority refused to recognise the right of X to deduct VAT on invoices for construction works. It considered that those construction works were not carried out by the service provider indicated in the invoices. Therefore, there was no an actual delivery under those invoices and there

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Refusal to delete police registration of a person - allowed by the national and European legislation, Personal data contained in the police registration

EuroCases Summary

After the completion of the criminal proceedings against X with an approved by the court agreement, X requested from the Director of General Directorate 'Criminal Police' (the Director) with the Ministry of Interior the deletion of his criminal registration. The Director refused the deletion of the

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Priority of the Aarhus convention over the provisions of the national and European legislation in the field of access to public information, Access to documents related to the environment and the programmes in the field of envionment

EuroCases Summary

X filed a request with the Minister of the Environment and the Waters (the Minister) for access to public information in the form of documents related to the priority axis 'Waste' of the Operational Programme 'Environment'. The Minister asked the municipalities concerned by the X's request for

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Insufficiency of the resources, Burden of proof, Reality of the delivery, Right to deduct VAT

EuroCases Summary

The revenue authority refused to recognise the right of X to deduct VAT on invoices issued by two suppliers. The main considerations of the revenue authority were related mainly to previous deliveries, as well as to allegations of insufficient staff and material resources of the suppliers. X

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Conditions for a set-off, Set-off, Sanction for a future period, Direct payment

EuroCases Summary

The State Fund 'Agriculture' - Payment Agency (the Payment Agency) notified X by letter that it had withheld from the due payment of a subsidy a sanction for a future period. X contested the letter before the Blagoevgrad Administrative Court (Административен съд Благоевград, the BlgAC), which

... show more

 
EuroCases Keywords

Overdeclared area between 3 and 20% - sanction in the amount of doubled overdeclared area, Overdeclared area under 3% - granting of aid denied

EuroCases Summary

X applied before the State Fund 'Agriculture'- Payment Agency (the Payment Agency) for aid under several schemes for direct payment. During an inspection, the Payment Agency found that under one of the schemes, for which X applied, 1.38% of the area did not meet the requirements for subsidising,

... show more

 
62018CO0091
Document Summary

Ordonnance de la Cour (septième chambre) du 3 septembre 2020 – (Tsipouro)

(affaire C‑91/18 INT)

« Demande en interprétation – Irrecevabilité manifeste »

Procédure juridictionnelle – Interprétation d’arrêt – Conditions de recevabilité de la demande

(Statut de

... show more

 
62019CO0747
Document Summary

Ordonnance de la Cour (sixième chambre) du 29 avril 2020 –Rosellò/Italie

(affaire C‑747/19 P)

« Pourvoi – Article 181 du règlement de procédure de la Cour – Recours en responsabilité extracontractuelle dirigé contre un État membre »

... show more

 
62019CO0678
Document Summary

Ordonnance de la Cour (chambre d’admission des pourvois) du 20 novembre 2019 – Retail Royalty/Fashion Energy

(affaire C‑678/19 P)

« Pourvoi – Marque de l’Union européenne – Admission des pourvois – Article 170 ter du règlement de procédure de la Cour – Demande ne

... show more

 
62017CJ0687
Document Summary

Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 7 November 2019 — Aanbestedingskalender and Others v Commission

(Case C‑687/17 P) ( 1 )

(Appeal — State aid — Aid granted by the Netherlands authorities for the creation and introduction of the TenderNed electronic

... show more

 
Document Summary

Information Note on the Court’s case-law 233

October 2019

Batiashvili v. Georgia - 8284/07

Judgment 10.10.2019 [Section V]

Article 6

Article 6-2

Presumption of innocence

Applicability of Article 6 § 2 in the absence of “criminal charge” in circumstances where authorities had disseminated a manipulated

... show more

 
Document Summary

Information Note on the Court’s case-law 233

October 2019

Lewit v. Austria - 4782/18

Judgment 10.10.2019 [Section V]

Article 8

Positive obligations

Article 8-1

Respect for private life

Domestic courts’ failure to conduct comprehensive assessment in defamation claim: violation

Article 35

Article 35-1

show more

 
Document Summary

Information Note on the Court’s case-law 213

December 2017

Zadumov v. Russia - 2257/12

Judgment 12.12.2017 [Section III]

Article 46

Article 46-2

Execution of judgment

General measures

Not reasonable or practical to make any pronouncement on the necessity of general measures

Article 6

Article 6-3-d

Examination

... show more

 
Document Summary

Note d’information sur la jurisprudence de la Cour 203

Janvier 2017

Habran et Dalem c. Belgique - 43000/11 et 49380/11

Arrêt 17.1.2017 [Section II]

Article 6

Procédure pénale

Article 6-1

Procès équitable

Procédure contradictoire

Egalité des armes

Refus de laisser la défense accéder aux documents relatifs aux

... show more

 
Document Summary

Note d’information sur la jurisprudence de la Cour 203

Janvier 2017

Saumier c. France - 74734/14

Arrêt 12.1.2017 [Section V]

Article 14

Discrimination

Différence de niveau d’indemnisation atteignable par un blessé ou un malade selon que son état provient d’une faute de son employeur ou de celle d’un

... show more